Eyebrows: thick vs. thin

My natural brows are dark and thick. Once in a while I would pluck/trim them thin, but sometimes I would go too far and look ridiculous! And every time I do, my mom would say that thick brows look better on me because of my wide face. Below are pics of me with thick and thin brows.

thick brows

thin brows

When comparing these two pics I kinda agree with my mom. The first pic seems to deemphasize the width of my face. But I think the second pic makes my eyes stand out more. After all these years, I still don't know which brows look better on me. One thing I do realize is that I have to wear a good amount of eye makeup to balance out dark thick brows. 

Shannyn can pull off the thick brows. I like her, she has a unique look/face.